Archive:Savethe

From FreeCulture.org
Revision as of 04:19, 26 June 2004 by 128.12.66.7 (talk)
Jump to: navigation, search

Save The [ ]

What are our key arguments? Put text and links below these headings.


OVERALL RHETORIC

Hollywood Has Bought Off Congress

-Details of campaign donations



REASONS WHY INDUCE ACT IS BAD

The Bill is too broad

-Could outlaw the ipod

-Links to the fake legal complaints

This Stiffles technological innovation

- Who will create a new device if it could be misconstrued to "induce"

May Make Bad Business Sense

-The movie industry attacked the VCR the same way the music industry attacks p2p and then videos became the primary revenue source.

Even if the Bill does what it says it does, it is still bad

Re-hashing of why Sony decision was sound. COMPLETED by CC and CIS guys (waiting to be emailed to Jake)


Not as strong (let's make them stronger):

Restricts Free Speech

-

Wastes Taxpayer Money

-Do we have info on how this would be enforced? re: enforcement, doesn't this law just create liability? The enforcement piece of things is taken care of by the pirate act and HR 4077, I think.


BETTER SOLUTIONS

(this is where DHB comes in)

There's a Better Solution for FIlesharing"

This Does Nothing to Stop Child Pornography